Pixels to Paper Funnels

Welcome to a space where every edition delivers insights, strategies, and inspiration to fuel your advertising brilliance. 🤯

🚀 Pixels to Paper Funnels: How Smart Marketers Are Hacking Direct Mail Like Digital

Imagine if launching a direct mail campaign was as easy as creating a landing page. No weeks of planning. No mountains of paperwork. Just log in, set your goal, personalize your message, and hit send — with complete performance visibility.

This is no longer a fantasy. Direct mail has become a scalable, measurable, and hyper-personalized growth engine — just like digital. The only difference? It ends up in your customer’s hands, not their inbox.

Here’s how to treat direct mail as a performance channel using the 3P Framework: Personalization, Performance, and Print Retargeting.

Personalization: Make Every Piece Feel One-to-One

Personalization isn’t limited to emails. AI-powered platforms now pull real-time data from CRMs like Klaviyo to create individualized mailers. Imagine sending:

• A replenishment reminder for a customer running low on skincare.
• A category recommendation based on recent browsing.
• A VIP discount for repeat buyers.

Kettle & Fire triggered personalized mailers after cart abandonment, achieving a 15x ROAS. That’s performance most digital channels struggle to match.

Performance: Test, Track, and Optimize Like a Pro

Traditional direct mail was a one-and-done gamble. But now, it’s a continuous feedback loop. You can A/B test formats, offers, and creative — just like digital — while tracking results in real time.

Knix monitored cost per order (CPO) mid-campaign using Poplar and adjusted their messaging based on early performance data, achieving a $10 CPO — a metric that rivals top-performing digital campaigns. Book a free demo with Poplar and get a one-month trial of their Pro Plan (a $499 value) with no minimum spend.

Print Retargeting: Catch Customers When Digital Fatigue Hits

Ad fatigue is real. After seeing endless pop-ups and retargeting ads, consumers stop paying attention. But when a personalized postcard lands in their mailbox, it feels thoughtful and intentional.

Here’s how print retargeting works:

• Cart Abandonment: If a customer leaves without purchasing, mail them a personalized reminder within days.
• Lapsed Customers: Trigger re-engagement mailers to dormant users with exclusive offers.
• Post-Purchase Upsells: Promote complementary products after checkout.

The tactile nature of direct mail commands attention, making it a strategic tool when digital fails.

Direct mail isn’t a channel of the past — it’s the future of performance marketing. When treated like a digital funnel, it becomes a high-ROI growth lever.

The question isn’t whether direct mail is right for your business. The question is: How fast can you get started?

Together with Insense

Find your perfect niche influencers within 48 hours

Fact: Nailin' that creator-brand alignment is the secret to high-performing UGC and influencer partnerships 

Problem: Manually sifting through thousands of creators to find the perfect match is a time-consuming nightmare.

Solution: Insense.

You need Insense’s carefully vetted marketplace of 68,500+ UGC creators and micro-influencers from 35+ countries across the USA, Canada, APAC, Europe, and Latin America.

Dermatologists for your skincare brand? They’ve got it! Watch collectors? LGBTQ+ creators? They’ve got it!

2,000+ e-com, DTC, and Amazon brands are using Insense to find their perfect niche creators and run diverse collaborations from product seeding and gifting to TikTok Shop and affiliate campaigns, and whitelisted ads.

• Quip - received an 85% influencer activation rate (32/37 influencers posted)
• Any Age Activewear - quickly matched with mature female creators aged 50+ which boosted AOV by 20%

Try Insense yourself. 

Book a discovery call by April 4th and get a $200 bonus for your first campaign.

🚀  Reel of the Day

What Works:

The wrist flip effect makes the shoe swaps smooth and visually satisfying, keeping viewers hooked creating a sleek, high-end feel, reinforcing the brand's image as stylish and sophisticated.

The phrase “5 Shoes in Your Rotation” frames the brand as a must-have for every occasion, appealing to viewers looking to simplify their wardrobes.

By covering categories like everyday, skinny, dressy, chunky, and special shoes, Theoze cleverly positions itself as a one-stop shop for footwear needs.

This problem-solution format encourages viewers to think about their own shoe rotation, subtly driving purchase intent.

The short, loop-friendly format encourages multiple views as people replay to catch each shoe type.

Broader Insights:

Theoze’s reel is a smart, visually striking piece of content that blends product showcase with aspirational storytelling. It positions the brand as a solution for simplifying fashion choices, while the effortless transitions and satisfying visuals ensure high engagement and recall. 

Thanks for reading this edition! Keep pushing boundaries, testing ideas, and staying inspired. See you in the next edition with more ways to ignite your marketing success. 🥰