The Infinite Cart System

Welcome to a space where every edition delivers insights, strategies, and inspiration to fuel your advertising brilliance. 🤯

🚀 The Infinite Cart System: How to Make Every Ad Click Perpetually Valuable

Most brands treat ads like a one-shot transaction—run an ad, get a sale, move on. But that’s a losing game. The smartest brands don’t just optimize for conversion. They design a system where a customer’s cart never really closes.

Instead of pushing people to buy once and hoping they return, they engineer a self-sustaining buying loop—one that keeps customers purchasing without additional acquisition costs.

Here’s how to build an Infinite Cart System that transforms every buyer into an ongoing revenue machine.

1️⃣ The “Always Open” Cart – Train Customers to Think in Continuation, Not Completion

Customers are more likely to add items over time if they know their cart isn’t a “one-time event” but a continuously evolving experience.

How to Do It:

• Persistent Cart Memory – Use a tool like Repeat, Skio, or Recharge to keep a customer’s cart “active” for 30+ days. Every time they return, they see previously browsed & recommended items pre-loaded.
• “Reserved For You” Items – Keep out-of-stock or wishlisted items visible in their account with priority access alerts (e.g., “Your reserved items are back—checkout before they’re gone!”).
• Exclusive Cart Perks – Offer progress-based incentives (e.g., “Your next order unlocks a free VIP upgrade”).

Example: Lume Deodorant increased repeat purchases by 36% by keeping previous orders visible in returning customers’ carts. 

2️⃣ Smart Retargeting – Make Customers Feel Like They’re Progressing, Not Just Being Reminded

Most retargeting ads fail because they feel like a pushy reminder. Instead, use psychological momentum.

How to Do It:

• “Continue Your Collection” Ads – Instead of generic “You forgot this,” retarget based on what they previously bought (e.g., “Complete Your Set – The final piece is waiting”).
• VIP Unlocks – Show progress-driven ads (e.g., “One more order unlocks early access to [exclusive drop]”).
• Auto-Refill Reminders – Instead of “Buy again,” use habit-based triggers (e.g., “Your routine is almost out—restock now”).

Example: Haus Wine increased reorders by 28% by triggering “refill before you run out” reminders at just the right time.

3️⃣ Post-Purchase Expansion – Keep Customers in the Buying Loop

Most brands go silent after checkout. That’s a fatal mistake. If you don’t engage within the first 72 hours, you’ve already lost them.

How to Do It:

• The “Future Access” Offer – Instead of sending a discount, create an exclusive “Next Order Perk” (e.g., “Your next purchase unlocks [limited item]”).
• One-Click Post-Purchase Add-Ons – Use tools like Carro or Rebuy to let customers add extra products after checkout with a single click.
• “Reserved Stock” Incentive – Create FOMO-driven urgency by holding back high-demand items only for previous customers (e.g., “Reserved for Our Inner Circle: You have 24 hours to claim it”).

Example: Athletic Greens reduces churn by reinforcing habit-building within the first 10 days, making customers feel like leaving means losing progress.

Final Takeaway: The Future of DTC Isn’t Just About Acquiring Customers—It’s About Making Sure They Never Stop Buying.

If you’re spending money on ads but not engineering a system that keeps those customers purchasing indefinitely, you’re burning cash. The best brands don’t just get sales—they create perpetual demand.

Together with Poplar

How Kettle & Fire leveraged direct mail to win back customers

Email and digital ad performance aren’t what they used to be, and brands are looking for new, efficient ways to reengage their customers and drive repeat purchases.

That’s why Kettle & Fire turned to direct mail with Poplar to reach valuable customers who simply weren’t engaging with their email campaigns.

Using Poplar’s easy Klaviyo integration, Kettle & Fire targeted lapsed customers who didn’t open their emails with a 1:1 mailer that fit into their existing Klaviyo workflows. Not only did this immediately boost the response rates of that group by 1.4%+, it drove over 15x ROI.

Don’t take our word for it, hear it from them directly: “We use Poplar for our win-back campaigns, and they’ve consistently shown a super high ROAS with personalized messaging and content.”

Want to see how direct mail can drive more conversions for your brand?

Book a free demo today!

🚀  Reel of the Day

The spin-the-wheel concept instantly hooks viewers by creating anticipation and curiosity—a strategy often used in interactive marketing.The gradual manipulation of the outcome builds suspense and humor, making viewers stay till the final moment (boosting watch time).

The "Save vs. Buy Clothes" dilemma is highly relatable, as many people struggle with impulse spending vs. financial discipline. The progression (shrinking the "Buy Clothes" option) exaggerates the real-life feeling of knowing you should save but still ending up shopping—making it instantly shareable.

The final spin landing on Saint Parel’s outfits subtly positions their clothing as the "destined choice", making the brand part of the joke rather than forcing a sale. Instead of directly promoting the clothes, the reel frames shopping as something fun and inevitable, which lowers purchase resistance.

Broader Insights:

This reel is a textbook example of how brands can leverage humor, psychology, and gamification to drive engagement and subtly influence purchase behavior. By making the audience laugh and relate, Saint Parel turns impulse shopping into an inevitable, feel-good decision. 

Thanks for reading this edition! Keep pushing boundaries, testing ideas, and staying inspired. See you in the next edition with more ways to ignite your marketing success. 🥰