Your Tests Are Lying

Welcome to a space where every edition delivers insights, strategies, and inspiration to fuel your advertising brilliance. 🤯

⏳ Your Tests Are Lying

Marketers love the 37% Rule: test a third of your options, then scale the first winner that beats the benchmark. It’s clean, simple, and mathematically elegant. But here’s the trap: testing alone no longer gives you the full picture.

Why? Because markets don’t exist in a vacuum. Your creative may clear your internal bar, but still fail in the real world because external factors, competitor saturation, shifting search visibility, or AI-generated product recommendations, shape the outcome before your ad even scales. That’s the blind spot most operators ignore.

The New Physics of Testing

In 2025, testing doesn’t just measure your ads. It measures your environment.

• Auction noise: Your CTR might look weak, not because of creative failure, but because a rival flooded the same audience with discounts that week.
• Search distortion: Customers consult AI search tools before clicking, and if you’re absent there, performance drags no matter how good the ad.
• Narrative bleed: Competitors condition audiences with claims and reviews that rewrite buyer expectations mid-test.

So even if you follow the 37% formula perfectly, you could be scaling into a market already tilted against you.

Rethinking the Exploration Phase

The key isn’t throwing out the 37% Rule. It’s redefining what “exploration” means. Instead of just testing creatives, you need to:

1. Audit external noise: See where rivals are pushing volume, so you don’t confuse market distortion with creative weakness.
2. Track brand mentions in AI search: If ChatGPT or Gemini already favors your competitors, your ads are climbing a steeper hill.
3. Time your tests: Don’t treat Q4 spike weeks or seasonal surges as “normal” testing environments; they skew your benchmarks.

Testing tells you how your ads perform inside your account. SEMrush’s AI SEO Toolkit shows how your brand performs in the wider battlefield of AI-powered discovery. It tracks whether your brand, or your competitors, show up in ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, or Gemini answers, and which prompts are driving visibility. 

That context helps you separate a true creative failure from an environmental problem. You can sign up for a 14-day free trial and monitor your brand’s AI search presence before you make your next scale decision.

The 37% Rule still works. But only if you realize the biggest risk isn’t stopping too soon or too late, it’s stopping based on incomplete signals. 

Internal metrics alone no longer guarantee clarity. Add an external lens, measure the market’s invisible hand, and you’ll know exactly when to stop testing and start scaling with confidence.

Together with Insense

1 Creator. 20+ Scroll-Stoppers. All in Your Hands by Next Week.

Media budgets can grow overnight, but creative output often lags. Shoots stretch, edits pile up, and CPAs climb while campaigns wait for fresh assets. Insense gives you speed and scale:

• One brief → 20+ ad variations per creator, raw and edited
• Under $150 per creator, delivered in 14 days or less
• Lifetime usage rights for unlimited remixing across Meta, TikTok, and YouTube

Growth teams at Forge Athletics and Harbor Peak Gear doubled weekly test volume and cut production costs by 30% by handing a single brief to Insense. Creative finally matched their media spend, without extra hires or agency delays.

Put 20+ fresh variations into rotation and have a complete library of ready-to-run ads in just two weeks, ready before your next campaign kicks off.

Book a free strategy call by September 26th and claim a $200 bonus towards your first campaign!

🎥Reel of the Day

What Works and Insights:

1. Runway as Retail Stage - Transforming a live NYFW street setup into a branded fragrance experience turns a seasonal event into a global launchpad. Brands can replicate this by embedding product rituals directly into cultural moments, showcasing scents mid-sport, so the product becomes a live spectacle rather than a static placement.

2. Luxury Collab Equity - Partnering with a fashion designer at NYFW extends Sol de Janeiro’s brand equity from body care to high-fashion credibility. Brands can scale this idea by aligning with aspirational partners in adjacent categories, building instant cachet and tapping into new consumer tribes without diluting their own heritage. 

3. Community Amplification Loop - Crowd reactions, phones out, and spontaneous filming turn a single activation into hundreds of micro-influencer posts. Brands can operationalize this by structuring events with intentional “share triggers”  that encourage organic UGC and extend campaign life far beyond the live moment.

Final Takeaway

This reel shows how a heritage-rich product can dominate a cultural flashpoint by making the brand experience impossible to ignore. The growth unlock lies in fusing product, place, and performance so seamlessly that every passerby becomes both participant and distributor.

Thanks for reading this edition! Keep pushing boundaries, testing ideas, and staying inspired. See you in the next edition with more ways to ignite your marketing success. 🥰