Too many collection pages hurt

Welcome to a space where every edition delivers insights, strategies, and inspiration to fuel your advertising brilliance. 🤯

🗂️ What a site with 180,000 URLs and four indexed pages teaches large catalogs

Google crawled one website 1.17 million times over several weeks and indexed four of its pages.

Google's John Mueller discussed the case on Bluesky on October 6. The product aggregator site had 180,000 URLs. The homepage wasn't among the four indexed. Mueller also noted that many indexed URLs redirected to the homepage, and said auto-generated aggregator content makes it hard to convince search engines of a site's value.

Even a well-run store can build the same pattern through its filters.

How filters multiply

Twelve colors, eight sizes and 30 categories make 2,880 combinations. Add sort orders and pagination, and a 600-product store can expose tens of thousands of URLs.

Each one asks Google for crawl time. Most offer nothing a parent category doesn't.

Run your own numbers

Open the Page indexing report in Search Console and note three counts:

• Indexed pages
• "Crawled, currently not indexed"
• "Discovered, currently not indexed"

If the two not-indexed counts together are more than five times your indexed count, crawl budget is likely going to the wrong pages. That ratio is my judgment.

Then open Crawl stats and check which URL patterns Googlebot requests most. Parameters like sort, view and page often dominate.

Sort every filter page into one of three groups

Earn a place. Combinations people actually search, such as "women's black wool coat." Give each a clean URL, a unique title, a short intro and links from the parent category.

Serve shoppers only. Combinations useful while browsing but with no search demand. Point their canonical tag at the parent category, or add noindex.

Don't block a page in robots.txt and expect noindex to work too. Google can't see a noindex tag on a page it isn't allowed to crawl.

Stop generating. Combinations with zero to two products. Remove the links that create them. Pages already live can return a 404.

Avoid the homepage redirect

When retiring filter pages, don't redirect them all to the homepage, which is the pattern Mueller flagged. Redirect to the closest category, or let them return a 404.

Before Black Friday

Keep one permanent URL for your Black Friday collection and reuse it every year, instead of creating a new dated page each season. Its links and history build up over time.

Track the fix

Check the Page indexing counts monthly. The not-indexed total should fall while indexed pages and organic clicks hold or rise.

Three numbers to pull today

Open Page indexing and write down the three numbers. If the ratio is badly off, filters are the first place to look.

Together with SuvreyMonkey

SurveyMonkey Will Do the Research for Your Next Campaign

Before you approve the next campaign, find out whether buyers respond to its message. That feedback is far more useful while you can still change the creative.

SurveyMonkey does the research work for you. Set up your study and select your audience. It handles paid-panel recruitment and automatically analyzes the responses.

• Compare up to 10 messages with your target audience to decide which deserves your campaign budget.
• Get your creative evaluated against industry benchmarks, with findings that show what needs improving before launch.
• Discover which product benefits buyers prioritize, so your ads and landing pages emphasize what matters to them.

With a multimillion-dollar Super Bowl campaign at stake, ClickUp used SurveyMonkey to test its ad with 5,000+ people in less than a week before choosing which version to air.

Give your next creative brief customer evidence your team can act on before production and media costs are committed.

⚡Amazon ranking depends on sales momentum and conversion

This framework argues that strong Amazon rankings come from generating consistent unit sales while maintaining a competitive listing. Advertising and deals can accelerate early momentum, helping products gain visibility and potentially increase organic sales.

Why it works: Higher sales velocity and strong conversion performance can support better visibility. As organic sales grow, brands may become less dependent on paid traffic, improving overall acquisition efficiency and TACoS.

Where it needs balance: Amazon's Best Sellers Rank primarily reflects sales performance, while organic keyword rankings involve additional relevance and performance signals. Aggressive promotions don't guarantee lasting rankings, and profitability depends on margins, advertising costs, and sustained demand after discounts end.

🎥 Reel of the Day

What Works:

1. Humor Creates The Hook - The reel opens with a playful confrontation about Enzo’s bad breath, turning an everyday pet care concern into an entertaining conversation that immediately captures attention.

2. Pet Reactions Drive Engagement - Enzo’s expressive face, tongue movements, and playful responses make the interaction entertaining. These unscripted-looking moments encourage viewers to watch longer and share the relatable exchange.

3. Demonstration Makes Benefits Tangible - Close-up shots of the container and dental powder show viewers exactly what the product looks like. The creator explains its intended benefits while positioning it as a convenient alternative.

Turn a common customer frustration into a humorous conversation featuring a relatable character. Build curiosity through their reactions, then introduce the product as a practical solution with a simple demonstration.

🥳 Events 

🔥 How Top Brands Measure, Fund, and Scale Creator Marketing

October 21 | Online | Free Festival

Return on Influence Festival ’26 brings together teams from Adobe, Edelman, ŌURA, Ogilvy, and more to unpack how creator programs actually run. Learn how they measure ROI, justify budget, structure partnerships, and scale from 5 to 5,000 creators without adding chaos.

✅ Secure Your Spot

Can't attend every session live? Register anyway, and you’ll get the recordings in 24 hours.

🔥 Where to Put Your Next Growth Dollar Beyond Meta

October 29 | The Glasshouse, NYC | Free In-Person Event

Hear how Reddit CEO Steve Huffman thinks about discovery, how Cody Plofker helped scale Jones Road Beauty to nine figures, and how brands like Liquid I.V. and MANSCAPED use TV to drive measurable revenue. Bring your hardest acquisition question and leave with a sharper channel plan.

✅ Reserve Your Spot

Advertise with Us

Wanna put out your message in front of over 40,000 best marketers and decision makers?

Here's our Partner Kit here🤝

Thanks for reading this edition! Keep pushing boundaries, testing ideas, and staying inspired. See you in the next edition with more ways to ignite your marketing success. 🥰